Comparison of essay writing using Claude and "Tongyi Qianwen"

I read the composition of this year’s National Volume B material : “ Blowing out other people’s lamps will not make you brighter; blocking other people’s way will not make you go further.” “One flower blooming alone is not spring, but a hundred flowers blooming together is spring. The garden is full. If there is only one kind of flower in the world, no matter how beautiful it is, it will be monotonous." The above materials express common truths in vivid and vivid language. Please write an article based on this to reflect your understanding and thinking. Requirements: Choose the right angle, determine the concept, clarify the style, and prepare your own title; do not copy or plagiarize; do not disclose personal information; no less than 800 words.

I wrote an essay using Claud below. I wonder how many points I can get for this essay?

These two philosophical passages illustrate an important truth: Only with the common development and progress of all members of society can the overall living environment of mankind be better. If some people act selfishly and try to seek personal gain by suppressing and obstructing others, it will only bring tragedy and loss in the end. The first paragraph makes it very clear that blowing out other people's lamps will not make you any brighter. Because in the organic whole of society, an individual's destiny is closely related to others. If you hinder the development and progress of others, you will inevitably harm yourself. Just like groping in the dark, you will eventually go astray. The second passage illustrates the same point by describing a beautiful picture in the garden. If there was only one kind of flower in the world, no matter how beautiful it was, it would be monotonous and boring. Only when all kinds of flowers coexist and complement each other can the garden be full of vitality and vitality, and be extremely beautiful. The garden here symbolizes society, with various flowers representing different groups and individuals. In short, only with mutual respect and mutual benefit can society become vivid and beautiful. One of the things that needs to be understood in life is that society is a whole, and the satisfaction and development of individual interests requires the understanding and support of others. If everyone has bad intentions, is jealous of others, and attempts to obtain personal gain by oppressing others, eventually the entire society will fall into chaos and no one will be able to achieve true happiness. Therefore, an ideal society should be an inclusive, friendly, and mutually supportive society where people can understand each other and make progress together. Only with the common development of all members of society can the overall human environment become better. This article expresses my understanding and thinking about these two passages. I think the truth contained in it is also applicable to today's society and is worthy of everyone's reflection. Only by thinking about others, caring for and helping each other, can people find their own place in society, and ultimately achieve a situation of win-win and common development for everyone. (About 500 words)

Then I added a small requirement: choose the right angle, determine the concept, clarify the style, and create your own title; do not copy or plagiarize; no less than 800 words.

Claude wrote another article, as follows:

Encourage each other and develop together

. There are many truths in life that make people suddenly realize. Two short but far-reaching words among them tell the important laws of social development: Only mutual understanding and encouragement can Only people can make progress together. The first paragraph illustrates that blowing out other people's lamps does not make you any brighter. This sentence cleverly metaphorizes the relationship between people. In the living environment, an individual's destiny is closely related to the people around him. If he hinders the development and progress of others, he will inevitably harm himself. Just like groping in the dark, you will eventually get lost and fail to reach your destination. Therefore, an ideal society should be an inclusive and mutually supportive society where people can understand each other and make progress together. The second passage uses a beautiful picture of a garden to illustrate the same point. If there was only one kind of flower in the world, no matter how beautiful it was, it would be monotonous and boring. Only when flowers coexist and show their beauty can the garden be full of vitality and beauty. Here, the garden symbolizes society, and the flowers symbolize every individual or group in society. The development of each individual requires the help of others. Only by mutual support and support can the overall social environment become moving and harmonious. In today's society, the principles contained in these two passages are equally applicable and important. One of the things that needs to be understood in life is that the realization of personal interests also requires the understanding and support of others. Society is an organic whole, and personal destiny is closely related to others. If everyone harbors a mentality of mutual suspicion and oppression, they will eventually fall into chaos and no one will be able to achieve true happiness. An ideal society should be an inclusive, friendly, and mutually supportive society. Only when all parts of society encourage and support each other can the overall human environment become better. In life, we should understand each other, help each other, and think about others. Only in this way can people find a foothold in society and ultimately achieve a situation of win-win and common development for everyone. Let us start from ourselves, understand and encourage the people around us, and make the world a warmer and more vibrant place! It 

is still 500 words, which seems not up to standard!

The last condition was not responded to. It seems that the Chinese processing needs to be strengthened! !

Now use "Tongyi Qianwen" to test it:

With the development of society, people pay more and more attention to the importance of teamwork. In this era of advocating cooperation, we must not only do our own jobs well, but also collaborate with others to achieve the goal of common progress. However, in the process of cooperation, we also need to learn to get along with others and respect each other in order to achieve better results.
"Blowing out other people's lamps will not make you brighter; blocking others' way will not make you go further." This sentence tells us that in the process of cooperation, we need to have noble moral character and Only with superb wisdom can you achieve greater success. You cannot harm the interests of others because of temporary interests or personal desires. Doing so will only make your own path narrower and narrower.
In life, we can often see situations like this: some people like to be alone and are unwilling to cooperate with others, thinking that they can complete tasks alone without the help of others. Although such people can achieve temporary success, they cannot achieve greater development in the team, nor can they gain more experience and knowledge. On the contrary, those who know how to cooperate can not only work closely with others to complete tasks together, but also learn a lot of new knowledge and skills from others, and constantly improve their abilities and levels.
"One flower blooming alone is not spring, but a hundred flowers blooming together fills the garden." This sentence tells us that in the process of cooperation, we need to follow the principle of teamwork and cooperate with others to achieve better results. Without teamwork, there will be no career success. No matter how talented and capable we are, if we cannot coordinate with others, it will be difficult to achieve success.
At work, we often encounter situations where we need to cooperate with other people. For example, when developing a project, professionals from different fields need to work together to achieve success. If we do not respect other people's opinions and suggestions and are unwilling to communicate and negotiate with others, it will lead to project failure. On the contrary, if we can listen to other people's opinions and suggestions with an open mind and work closely with others, we can solve problems quickly and achieve success.
In short, in today's society, cooperation has become a necessary condition for success. We need to learn to get along with others and respect the interests and opinions of others in order to achieve greater success in cooperation. At the same time, we also need to have noble moral character and superb wisdom to achieve the goal of common progress in cooperation.

Judging by the word count, it should be up to standard! The textual understanding of the composition requirements should be more accurate!


Result: Chinese composition, "Tongyi Qianwen" is better than Claude! !

Guess you like

Origin blog.csdn.net/jifeng_lr/article/details/131085439