**** a value of $ Smart3d (Context Capture) and Dajiang Chi diagram (DJI Terra) modeling evaluation

March Dajiang released "Dajiang Chi map" ground station, there are basic and professional versions of the points, base classes can be purchased directly at Dajiang official website, monthly, annual purchase a license.

See the introduction not only to control UAV aerial survey (setting line, automatic flight), while flying a map, it is really very powerful.

Today there got from Dajiang Dajiang Chi Figure Pro license (thanks to Huang), took the opportunity to do some comparison and Smart3D modeling (osgb format model).

Whatever the outcome as a first point of Dajiang praise.

First, the cool interface:


4991652-361c647e3526976b.png

Second, the New Task (tilt Photography)

4991652-3372ff5266af7b9a.png

Third, the default name for the Chinese (my real heart startled, or China-made software to understand the people ah)

4991652-2667830491b13ff7.png

Fourth, into the reconstruction options

4991652-ce5d641fa7d3c5ba.png

Fifth, after importing import photos :( optional deletion, continue to add)


4991652-e0951c2adf30c81f.png

Sixth, began to rebuild (rebuild only tilt, model format two options can be set)

Not an additional operation

4991652-ed54a2e989f40817.png

Seven, start rebuilding (we click on)

Whether there will be a prompt to copy pictures (without copying, copy photos to guess the reason is to facilitate future restoration projects, to prevent accidental deletion)

4991652-3a476cf6e706d86b.png

Eight, wait

Points [with photos], [rebuilding], whether behind the other I do not know, no long wait has been sitting at a computer

4991652-324cbf446a8e3207.png

Nine, to see the results


4991652-a20bde0291cab957.png
4991652-2d39a9febb07364a.png
Automatic digital project named
4991652-7cb492699c45816a.png
There are images and the results under both kinds mdoels

images are procedural texture, models are models

4991652-3cac6652f7d900b0.png
pc file in the models folder
4991652-06148f3c40777bbd.png
0 pc following folder
4991652-7ae7d6a19d10f7c5.png
Results-based format

3 types of format to see results, b3dm (cesium format), osgb, ply (a model that can be exported in the form solidworks)

10. Comparative results (first and osg generated before processing performed by smart3d some comparison)

For accuracy, where choice osgviewer comparison (Dajiang left and right smart3d)


4991652-2783f05c4859628a.png


4991652-3cd47d3b92ab8420.png
4991652-6a0767456160ee9a.png

Contrast key:

Ease of use: Dajiang few extra steps; smart3d need aerial triangulation, reconstruction, production; Dajiang win

Root: root Dajiang comes automatically merged; Smart3D root node must generate merged separately, and a high failure rate; Jiang big win

Nodes: Dajiang automatic block 8; Smart3D machine according to the memory 36 points; Jiang big win

成果体积:大疆2.47G;smart3d 486M(也许和选择的模型质量相关)

面平整度:两者基本一致

纹理效果:见图,smart3d更胜一筹

osgb文件总数:大疆14775;smart3d 3134;smart3d完胜

osg加载速度:放大缩小查看,大疆慢,smart3d快(应该和节点个数相关)

范围设置:大疆自动,smart3d可自由设置(smart3d更灵活)

处理时间:大疆6小时,smart3d,时间忘了(好像超过了6个小时)

osgb版本:大疆应该是3.6左右,smart3d应该是3.2以上都兼容

osg模型结构分析:

一个tile下的osgb文件分级情况(说明这里不对比文件个数问题,因为同等电脑配置下大疆的分块个数远小于smart3d):

对于他们的分级标准是否一致,未做验证(是否level代表的是指定的分辨率?)

大疆(不含tile根节点是从15-22级,共8级):

Model.osgb、Model_L15_0_0.osgb、Model_L16_0_0.osgb、******、Model_L22_15_63.osgb

smart3d(不含tile根节点是从17-23级,共7级)

Tile_+000_+000.osgb、Tile_+000_+000_L17_0.osgb、Tile_+000_+000_L18_00.osgb、******、Tile_+000_+000_L23_0003300.osgb

看一组对比图吧


4991652-09724d5544c43b69.png
model,15,16,17四级别的数据效果


4991652-99bb97883f6de56a.png
samrt3d,根节点、17,18,19,20,21六级别的数据效果

最精细级别,三角网效果(网格结构完全不一致啊):


4991652-faf028869daf7e54.png
左dji,右smart3d
4991652-0f08f981445f43fe.png
左dji,右smart3d
4991652-07d1144c4b0e4b6f.png
左dji,右smart3d

纹理结构分析:


4991652-48be398d47eb35bb.png
dji,8192*8192


4991652-d57c57abfd930ce3.png
smart3d,8192*4096


最后附上web查看地址:

dji

http://online.wish3d.com/Wish3DEarth/LSGlobe/scene.html?guid=a5b20db57134158eb9695673961ab711&IS_PACKAGE=0&token=181fb765-3e3b-4751-adb5-8dd62aa44978

smart3d

http://online.wish3d.com/Wish3DEarth/LSGlobe/scene.html?guid=25f360eb313414c190897d5f7b2c989f&IS_PACKAGE=0&token=181fb765-3e3b-4751-adb5-8dd62aa44978

I enclose my computer configuration:

Graphics: NVIDIA 980ti

cpu:i7-6800k @3.4GHz

Memory: ddr4 16G

Some news:

Before I heard Dajiang and bently cooperation, thinking Dajiang tilt processing and smart3d will be basically the same, the moment bently may still have reservations.

Process and look at the results of the block, and a model of a structure is not like.

Results Dajiang and personnel communication, an entirely independent research and development, the original reports of cooperation and Dji terra nothing to do.

statement:

From the above comparison of personal interest and do not represent the official.

Contrast generated positive photo

Guess you like

Origin blog.csdn.net/weixin_33727510/article/details/91035080